A Social Media Experiment: TDI Club Forum

In my Social Media Marketing course I ran an impromptu social media test. It started when my car wouldn’t start on the first day of classes. The local garage quoted me $450 to $650 for an alternator. After just spending a couple hundred on the brakes I sought another solution by visiting the TDI Club Forums.

Then in class we talked about the big shift in Web 1.0 to 2.0 where people communicate directly with user generated content through social networks instead of being passive receivers of what large organizations choose to share. That’s when I thought of the experiment.

You see, veteran TDI Club member “Wingnut” from Toronto detailed, with pictures, how to replace an alternator and convinced me that I could do it too. I said that if I could successfully fix my car from a forum post, then Web 2.0 has really shifted power to the people – even a professor who spent his previous career creating ads not fixing cars.

I found a new alternator at Auto Parts Warehouse for $150 and a coupon code that saved me more money. Within days it arrived, I had it in my car in less than three hours and the car is running great! The check engine light even turned off and that has been on for years.

I am now on the Auto Parts Warehouse email list and have “Liked” their Facebook page with 34,000 other empowered car owners.

In full discloser, I did receive help from my wife’s uncle who is mechanically inclined but not an auto mechanic. He also admitted afterward that he wasn’t sure if we could do it. But we did.

So social media passed the test. Consumers are empowered and that means marketers must learn new ways to engage them. The good news is engaged consumers may be worth more money in the long run.

A new eBook by Sitecore indicates that fully engaged customers represent a 23% premium compared to average customers in terms of share of wallet, profitability, revenue and relationship growth. The problem is 87% of customers are currently disengaged. How could marketers in and around the auto industry further engage empowered consumers?

20120916-184131.jpg
The new alternator is in the center of the picture and gives you an idea of all the other engine parts that needed to be removed to get to it.

Afraid of Digital? History Says Run To It, Not Away

A report by the American Association of Publishers just announced that net sales revenue from ebooks exceeded that of hardcover books for the first time. Remember when many publishers and authors were scared of eBooks and fought against digital publishing? As late as 2005, J.K. Rowling did not permit any of the six Potter books to be released in electronic form.

But publishers are not alone in their fears. Remember the music industry and all their lawsuits against digital music? They weren’t just suing services like Napster, but suing thousands of individual music fans. In 1998, the Recording Industry Association of America filed a lawsuit claiming the Diamond Multimedia Rio PMP300 player violated the 1992 Audio Home Recording Act.

Then there’s the journalism profession. They didn’t want anything to do with news on the web and tried to preserve their old business model while others set the standard of free news on the Internet. First the readers left, then the advertisers. A recent article in The Online Journalism Review said it this way, “America’s newspaper chains missed their moment of opportunity to use their scale to dominate the information business online.” Now they’re trying to play catch up online and on mobile by trying to convince people to pay subscriptions again.

Today marketers are at the crossroads these other industries faced in the past. Social Media Marketing is about giving up control – something corporations and marketing people are not used to doing. And that means open, responsive “social” interactions – not using facebook as an event calendar or a place to post static press releases.

Are we going to learn from history? Or let fear hold us back?